Tulsa and Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, are two cities with a rich history and culture. However, they also have their share of unsolved mysteries that continue to intrigue residents and visitors alike. In this blog post, we will explore five unsolved mysteries in Tulsa and Broken Arrow.
- The Missing Welch Girls
On December 30, 1999, 16-year-old Ashley Freeman and her best friend, 16-year-old Lauria Bible, disappeared from Welch, Oklahoma. They were last seen at a sleepover at Ashley’s family’s trailer. The next day, the trailer was discovered burned to the ground with the bodies of Ashley’s parents, Danny and Kathy Freeman, inside. However, Ashley and Lauria’s bodies were never found. The case remains unsolved, and no one has been charged with the crime.
- The Disappearance of Shane Montgomery
In 2014, 21-year-old Shane Montgomery disappeared after a night out with friends in Philadelphia. He was last seen leaving a bar in the Manayunk neighborhood. Despite an extensive search, including diving into the Schuylkill River where he was believed to have fallen in, no trace of Shane was found. In 2015, his body was finally discovered in the river, but his death remains a mystery.
- The Case of the Vanishing Hotel Guest
In 1967, a man checked into the Tulsa Hilton Inn under the name “Eugene K. Scott.” He stayed for several weeks and paid in cash. One day, he simply disappeared, leaving behind all his belongings, including a large sum of money. The hotel staff searched for him but could not find any trace of him. No one knows who Eugene K. Scott really was or why he vanished.
- The Murder of the Wagoner County Girls
In 1992, three girls, 13-year-old Misty Copsey, 16-year-old Lauria Bible (mentioned earlier in this post), and 15-year-old Jennifer Schmidt, went missing from Wagoner County, Oklahoma. Lauria Bible’s body was later found, but Misty and Jennifer’s bodies were never found. The case remains unsolved, and it is believed that all three girls were victims of a serial killer.
- The Disappearance of Rebecca Triska
In 1995, 19-year-old Rebecca Triska disappeared from her Broken Arrow apartment. She was last seen by her roommate, who reported hearing a scream and then saw a man leaving the apartment complex. Rebecca’s car was found abandoned in the parking lot, and her purse was inside. Despite an extensive search, no trace of Rebecca has ever been found.
In conclusion, these unsolved mysteries in Tulsa and Broken Arrow are reminders of the dark side of human nature and the mysteries that continue to baffle law enforcement and the public alike. Hopefully, with advances in technology and new leads, these mysteries will one day be solved, bringing closure to the families and communities affected by these tragedies.