What To Expect

Private murder mystery show guest pointing finger gun

Get Ready For The Night Of Your Life!

The Dinner Detective is an experience unlike any other! We offer an amazing murder mystery show paired with a fantastic four-course  dinner. Our actors are dressed like everyone else, so anyone in the room can end up being part of the show, including YOU!

If you have any questions about The Dinner Detective that aren’t answered below, please  email us at [email protected]! Or you can call our National Box Office Tue-Fri 11am-6pm EST and Sat 11am-2pm at (866) 496-0535, . Please note: the national box office is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Does The Show Work?

  • PLEASE NOTE: Prop guns, loud simulated gunshots, and short lighting blackouts are used as part of the performance!
  • Our show does not have a theme or time period, and our performers are not in costume! Unlike traditional murder mystery dinner shows, we do not set our shows in the Old West, on Kong Island, or in the 1800’s. All of our stories are set in the present day, and all of our performers are dressed just like everyone else!
  • The action happens throughout the entire room! Throughout the night, a crime will occur, hidden clues will come forth, and our Detectives will help everyone try to solve the crime. In the end, we have a Prize Package for the Top Sleuth who comes closest to cracking the case!
  • You can choose whether or not to participate in the show! Our guests are encouraged but not required to perform or participate. However,  other audience members may interact with and interrogate you on their own.
  • The show takes place all around you! We also ensure each table gets to see every clue and witness every important scene, so all guests have an equal chance to solve the mystery!
  • AGE RESTRICTION: The Dinner Detective is a show geared toward adults. We have a strict age limit of 15 years old, due to mild adult content, loud noises, and swearing.
  • PLEASE NOTE: You will be required to bring your confirmation page, a valid ID, and the credit card used during purchase to gain admission to your chosen performance.

Where Is The Venue?

  • We perform at the 22 Warren St NY, NY 10007.  Click HERE for a map and directions.

What Is The Suspect Package?

  • The Suspect Package is a great way to get your party directly involved in the mystery! This optional package lets you get a member of your party involved in the show as a Prime Suspect WITHOUT THEIR KNOWLEDGE. This is a great added perk where we will use your guest as a red herring to trick the audience into believing they are involved in the mystery plot. This package has a one-time per-party fee of $19.95.

How Does Seating & Food Service Work?

  • Our venue and their kitchens are able to accommodate dietary requests such as gluten free, dairy free, etc. as long as we know at time of order. PLEASE NOTE: We cannot guarantee dietary restrictions or allergies will be honored unless we are notified of those restrictions/allergies at the time of your order!
  • All guests will be assigned seats at maximum 10-person round banquet tables. If you have multiple parties attending, please ask your party members to mention the last name of your original party in the Party Seating Request section during the order process. If your group is larger than 10, we will do our best to split the group equally and seat you at adjacent tables unless otherwise instructed. PLEASE NOTE: We cannot guarantee seating requests will be honored unless we are notified of those requests at the time of your order!

What About Rescheduling, Transfers & Refunds?

  • Once your purchase has been completed, all sales are final! We cannot refund or cancel any orders due to our theatrical and venue contracts.
  • You may transfer your reservation(s) to another show date with 7 or more days’ notice. A $20/person transfer fee is required. Please email [email protected] or call (866) 496-0535 to transfer your tickets.

What People Are Saying

★★★★★ “Absolutely amazing experience that entertains any age or type of person. Highly recommended, will go back again. Not tasks at all and crowd is constantly laughing.”– Ashley W., Yelp Review

★★★★★ “I attended The Dinner Detective show last weekend and it was so much fun! The surprises that kept coming had me on my toes and paying attention to try and figure out the mystery. Definitely something i’d go to again and would recommend to others.”

– Kristy G., Facebook Review

★★★★★ “The actors were very professional, and they were great at reacting to the audience. Add to all that a very good sit-down dinner, and you’ve got a night to remember. I highly recommend it!”

– Patti J., Google Review